Hi everyone I was just looking into signing up for the Home Depot credit card yesterday (which I found doesn't have that great of benefits) and I started wondering.. out of the three biggest box stores (Home Depot, Menards, Lowes) which one offeres the best programs and benefits for someone like me who is in there spending money every day on rehab projects. Looking at the stats from the market share, we can see that Home Depot ($195 billion) blew Loweâs ($72 billion) out of the water in 2018. On any given day; if you were to compare their prices âapples to applesâ they wonât very far apart. A large lumber company in our area with lumber yards in many towns. 84 Lumber Prices vs. Loweâs vs. Home Depot: Lumber Reviewed. The alleged deception: Menards and Home Depot (HD) market and sell the hefty lumber as four-by-fours without specifying that the boards actually measure 3½ inches by â¦ 1 reason Menards is a tougher competitor than The Home Depot or Lowe's is because of Menards' image that they're the cheapest," says Joe Collings, owner of Ferguson Lumber Corp., with three locations near Indianapolis and 141 years of corporate history. Menard is the nation's third-largest home improvement chain behind Home Depot and Lowe's. Home Depot and Menards are each facing a possible class-action suit over claims they deceived lumber buyers over board sizes by using nominal sizes. Home Depot credit card saved my butt twice and I was able to get renters in there three and six months earlier than I would have had I had to finance it upfront. Lowes has always had the best customer and contractorâs services for big Home Improvement stores in every area of the country that we have located our business. Is there any difference in the quality of pressure treated lumber at Lowes or Home Depot? The extra months of rent I got, more than made up for any difference in price. x 2 in. They have no dedicated window firm. Follow. 2 in. Compare company reviews, salaries and ratings to find out if Menards or The Home Depot is right for you. For the deck project, the pre-tax total was slightly lower at Lowe's: $1,368.31 vs. $1,382.50 at Home Depot.On our more general shopping list, 11 products were cheaper at Lowe's, with average savings of just over â¦ Home improvement store battle- Home Depot vs. Lowe's vs. Menards- FIGHT! Its stores sell lumber and home improvement products such as hardware, tools and paint. x 2 in. The lawsuits against the retailers would-be class actions, filed within five days of each other in federal court for the Northern District of Illinois. Next time youâre in Menards for home supplies, cruise through the grocery section. Compare working at Menards vs The Home Depot. When visiting those cities with all 3 retailers, including Menards, the people employed by Menards, especially in lumber and other building materials used in construction, were easier to find, more helpful and easier to ask questions of than both Home Depot and Lowe's. It might be warped; have a split in it or a chunk is missing. The 2x4 and 4x4 boards used in the framework of most homes and wood fences just don't measure up to the dimensions in their names. Before The Home Depot, a person (usually a man) would go to what was called a "lumberyard" in conjunction with a "hardware store" to fill the home remodeling list.Employees of these lumberyards and hardware stores could often be grouchy, unhelpful, and clubby, hardly a welcoming environment for anyone who wasn't part of the club. 3.5. Wait times for help in this category were more favorable at Menards. 9 years ago. Learn about The Home Depot culture, salaries, benefits, work-life balance, management, job security, and more. They have a large selection in stock ready to take home â¦ I worked for depot in appliances from 06-07 before coming to Lowe's. Menards. Sort by: Oldest. anyone ever compare the 2's products and prices when shopping for replacement windows? x 2 in. One huge advantage Lowe's has is appliances, we stock a ton of them in store, which is good for people wanting to take home today, as well as being able to deliver the next day.. That being said, on the Renno part two, I did incorporate some local vendors and had a good experience. They have a great selection of full-size displays where you can really touch and feel the exterior doors. Often it may be a leftover from a larger piece cut for another customer. Cull lumber is lumber that has been pulled from inventory because it is damaged in some way or is a piece leftover from trimming. The plaintiffs are seeking more than $5 million. Lowe's,but i have found the local lumber yards a little cheaper and far better Quality.recently i checked on the price of 5"cove molding at home depot and found the same at a local lumber yard 1.28 a foot less.and the Quality was far better .same go,s for a lot of gardening Supply,s Chick the local hardware stores.you will be surprised. Home Depot vs Lowes pressure treated lumber. If you want the beautiful and natural look of wood for your project with added benefits and protection, head to Menards ® for top-notch treated wood products! 9 years ago. Better Buy: The Home Depot vs. Lowe's These home-improvement competitors are similar in many ways, but Lowe's needs one thing to beat Home Depot. My opinion on this has changed very recently. J. They buy and sell from whoever is the cheapest. All of the big box stores routinely monitor their competitorsâ promoted sales and regular everyday prices. Like; Save; cruzmisl. Create a level surface for attaching wallboard and paneling. We also priced out materials needed to build an outdoor deck. Our treated decking and porch flooring allows you to create the perfect outdoor living space, and our treated dimensional lumber is treated to a minimum of ground contact use, making it ideal for framing and â¦ My preferences are in this order : 1. One true aspect is the maintaining for the lumber. Compare prices, policies, and customer reviews of Menards and Home Depot NO diferance at all. We researched prices on the most common types and sizes of lumber used in building and home improvement projects at three major stores: Loweâs, The Home Depot, and 84 Lumber. Revenue reports by The Home Depot and Lowe's suggest they accounted for 31.0% and 21.0%, respectively of the market last year. Menards carries a wide range of groceries at a good discount. Cupping, warping, splitting is bound to happen with lumber. In the stores, they have banded bunks of lumber. x 8 ft. Furring Strip Board Lumber Every piece of 2 in. Menards is very reasonably priced, especially on Menards brand goods - master force, tool shop (gross), mastercraft, crest line, etc. Learn more, read reviews and see open jobs. Menards Vs. Home Depot for replacement windows? I used to be a diehard Home Depot guy, but they've let me down too many times. Email Save Comment 5. Menards is most highly rated for Job Security/Advancement and The Home Depot is most highly rated for Culture. "The No. Among Midwestern females, the attraction to Menards â¦ 998 reviews from The Home Depot employees about working as a Lumber Associate at The Home Depot. The alleged deception: Menards and Home Depot (HD) market and sell the hefty lumber as four-by-fours without specifying that the boards actually measure 3½ inches by 3½ inches. Newest; Oldest; Comments (5) john_hyatt. Treated or not. And over the past two years, shopper growth at Menards (+3.5%) has even outpaced Home Depot (+1.5%) in this region. Yet the general public still views Menards the same as Loweâs or The Home Depot â a big hardware store rather than an all-in-one shopping experience. That said, Loweâs is under new management and taking aggressive steps to close that gap. Lumber from Menards,HD, lowes is sourced from main mills/yards, like Potomac - OR whoever the buyer for the companies corp office deals with. I worked at Menards for almost 3 years, and miss the store every time I shop at depot or lowes. I'm not sure how your delivery from store goes, but we can deliver almost anything next day, mulch, lumber, 10 water â¦ Ship to Home Eligible (137) Ship to Store Eligible (116) ... Click to add item "2 x 4 Red Cedar Lumber - Rough Sawn" to the compare list. The other big box of note, Menards, is estimated by Forbes to have generated $9.5 billion in sales in 2017, so that would give it 2.9% of the market. For instance, a lumber piece listed as a 2x4 may actually measure only 1.5â x 3.5.â The lawsuit is similar to others brought earlier this year against home improvement retail giants Home Depot and Menards over the lumber sold by those stores, which similarly measures slightly less than the dimensions listed on the label. That is a great question and yes, that might be the perfect place to find your new entry door. Lowes, Menards or Home Depot? cruzmisl. x 8 ft. Furring Strip Board is perfect for a wide range of uses including carpentry, hobbies, shelving and general finish work. To compare Lowe's vs. Home Depot prices, we drew up a list of items from flooring to lumber to mulch. Source(s): ... We bought ours from McCoys. Menards and Home Depot stand accused of deceiving the lumber-buying public, specifically, buyers of 4x4 boards, the big brother to the ubiquitous 2x4. x 8 ft. Furring Every piece of 2 in. Thanks, Joe . Letâs compare Home Depot vs. Loweâs Pro Desk to see how the two big box stores stack up next to each other.